The Blogging Hounds

Canadian Prime Minister Mark Carney warned the United States to respect Canada’s sovereignty this week after reports surfaced that Alberta separatists had met with U.S. officials connected to President Donald Trump’s administration.

The reports ignited a political firestorm in Ottawa and British Columbia, where critics accused Alberta independence advocates of crossing a dangerous line. British Columbia Premier David Eby went further, branding the separatists “treasonous” — a charge that legal experts and constitutional scholars say does not withstand scrutiny.

Peets Coffee – Discover Mighty Leaf’s most popular teas. teas.

Carney Pushes Back on U.S. Contacts

Speaking publicly, Carney said he had made Canada’s position clear directly to Trump.

“I expect the U.S. administration to respect Canadian sovereignty,” Carney said. “I’m always clear with President Trump to that effect.”

Carney’s comments came amid reports that Trump officials had communicated with a separatist group in Alberta, Canada’s energy-rich western province, where dissatisfaction with federal energy policy and revenue redistribution has fueled a growing independence movement.

Alberta Premier Urges Restraint

Alberta Premier Danielle Smith also weighed in, calling for the United States to stay out of Alberta’s internal political process.

“I would expect that the U.S. administration would respect Canadian sovereignty and confine discussions about Alberta’s democratic process to Albertans and Canadians,” Smith said.

Smith stopped short of condemning the separatists themselves, reflecting the delicate political balance within a province where calls for independence are gaining traction.

Winter Survival Kit – 3-Month Emergency Food Kit w/ Over $400 in FREE Gifts

B.C. Premier Calls It ‘Treason’

The harshest rhetoric came from British Columbia’s Eby, who accused Alberta separatists of betraying the country.

“To go to a foreign country and ask for assistance in breaking up Canada — there’s an old-fashioned word for that,” Eby said. “And that word is treason.”

Eby also said he would not even describe the group as “Albertans,” arguing they were undermining national unity by seeking foreign engagement.

Why the ‘Treason’ Claim Falls Apart

Legal analysts point out that provincial separation is explicitly contemplated under Canada’s constitutional framework. Quebec held two referendums on independence — in 1980 and 1995 — without its leaders being charged with treason.

If Eby’s logic were applied consistently, critics ask, would the Bloc Québécois or Quebec sovereignty movements also be considered treasonous?

Moreover, meeting foreign officials as private citizens does not meet the legal threshold for treason under Canadian law, which is narrowly defined and historically reserved for acts involving armed conflict or direct aid to an enemy state.

Real Time Pain Relief – A Brand You Can Trust

Why Alberta’s Discontent Is Growing

Alberta’s separatist movement has been fueled by long-standing grievances: blocked energy export projects, aggressive climate regulations, and federal redistribution policies that many Albertans believe unfairly siphon oil revenues to other regions — including British Columbia.

Alberta borders the United States and depends heavily on U.S. trade, making cross-border discussions economically logical, even if politically controversial.

Jeffrey Rath, co-founder of the Alberta Prosperity Project, confirmed his group has traveled to Washington three times in the past year. He described the meetings as private, exploratory discussions — not requests for funding — including a feasibility review of a potential $500 billion line of credit should Alberta ever become independent.

A Question of Dissent, Not Treason

The escalating rhetoric raises a deeper question: is this really about treason, or about delegitimizing Western dissent?

Critics argue branding separatists as traitors is a convenient way to shut down uncomfortable conversations about Confederation, energy policy, and regional inequality — especially as frustration in Western Canada continues to grow.

Essante Organics – Your dream shop Guaranteed, Organic, Toxic Free, and pH Balanced Products. That’s It.

Conclusion

As Alberta separatists collect signatures for a referendum, Ottawa and provincial leaders are facing a reality they can no longer dismiss: Western alienation is no longer theoretical.

Whether or not Alberta ever leaves Canada, calling political dissent “treason” risks exposing deeper cracks in Canada’s democratic culture — and may accelerate the very divisions federal leaders claim to fear.

---

Affiliate Disclosure:
Some links in my articles may bring me a small commission at no extra cost to you. Thank you for your support of my work here!

EMP Shield’s family of products are designed to protect against electromagnetic pulse (EMP), lightning, power surges, and coronal mass ejection (CME)

 My Patriot Supply – Take advantage of limited-time deals on emergency food kits, water filtration, solar backup systems, and much more.